I've many progressive, white, liberal friends, but they usually don't identify themselves as such. They just go about their business, living their lives, doing the things they do. And then there are the self-identified liberals--those who waste no opportunity to acquaint us with their latest and most pressing cause or issue and their jargon. These folks are always looking out for the underdog or less fortunate. They use terms like "disenfranchised," "essentialized," "underclass." I can always count on these liberals to have my best interest at heart, and I can also count on them to know, even more than I, what my best interest is. Either life experience or erudition gives them an incredible understanding, empathy, if you will, of all things pertaining to race and social justice. I owe these liberals so much. They helped me get to where I am today. They make promises they can't possibly keep. The "problem" of "diversity" is never solved because what, then, would they have to do? Whom, then, would they protect? Who would be their cause?
I've been criticized by the liberals for the relationships I have with conservatives: Republicans, members of the NRA, flagwavers, staunch and firm believers in a "conservative" interpretation of the Constitution and Christians, devout and otherwise. It should be no surprise that some "conservatives" are very dear to me. There is a deep and abiding bond between us that goes beyond political positions and persuasions. These are people who have loved and supported me. I can count on them, and they can count on me. We do not have to agree. To them, I am simply a person--not a representative, not diversity or even a minority. I'm me.
Self-proclaimed liberals often judge people by their politics rather than, as Shelby Steele would say, "the content of their character." This version of liberal can only hang out with like-minded folks who speak their language and support their causes. In my institution, one of the most effective "recruiters" of faculty of color is a "patriarchal, conservative, far-right, gun toting, hunting, Republican." In addition to effective recruiting, this "right wing nut" was the most effective "retainer" of faculty of color as well. Every, single person of color in the department is happy and content. There was no well-meaning, patronizing, rhetoric. No "lowering of standards" as a nod to "diversity." Just a good person whose genuine commitment is immediately transparent to a prospective colleague.
Liberals suffocate, patronize, affirmative actionize, determine, run, rule with the smug self-assurance that they are always absolutely right. They pity those of us who get in the way; they attempt to crush and denigrate those who get in their way. There is nothing worse to a self-proclaimed liberal than a "minority" who doesn't get with the program--a minority who opposes and exposes them--a minority who refuses to capitulate to their rigid requirements for membership in the club. They will find one who will. These liberals have no credibility if they have no "minority" among them.
I seen you before, Ms. Liberal, and like the emperor, you ain't got no clothes. Peace out.
Monday, September 13, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I don't know, Marg . . . I'm sure I'm guilty of jargonizing and generally being annoying . . . but . . . I often really do have trouble being friends with conservatives because (I'm probably about to really step in it here) for me, politics are a natural outgrowth of the content of one's character. We're not born with "Republican" or "Democrat" or "Socialist" stamped on our butts. We choose these orientations for ourselves based on our values, just as we choose our friends based on our values. I do try to give people a chance even if I know they don't vote the same way I do, but--honestly--I've found in life that people who don't vote the same way I do often think I'm weird and perverse, say offensive stuff about people I love, condescend to the ideals I care most about, or experience my attempts to be a good citizen as snobbery. (I don't buy organic veggies to show off my fabulous wealth, nor do I judge others for not buying organic veggies, but I've noticed that the Republicans in my life can't help but give me a hard time when they notice my veggies are organic.) I guess it's true that lefties also sometimes share some of these characteristics, but--I think it's important to acknowledge that one's politics and the content of one's character are not unrelated.
ReplyDeletethree months late, but ive seen the emperor too.....she doubles as a social worker and other sundry low-level functionaries dedicated to helping "the system" *help* people with disABILITIES...ack!!
ReplyDelete